Head to Head
| Players Championship 13 | 2023/06/12 16:35 | Michael Smith v Gary Anderson | 8-7 |
| US Masters 2022 | 2022/06/04 23:40 | Michael Smith v Gary Anderson | 8-3 |
| Premier League Darts | 2022/04/28 19:10 | Michael Smith v Gary Anderson | 6-2 |
| Players Championship 9 2022 | 2022/04/01 13:00 | Michael Smith v Gary Anderson | 4-6 |
| Premier League Darts | 2022/03/17 22:05 | Michael Smith v Gary Anderson | 4-6 |
| Premier League Darts | 2022/03/10 19:10 | Gary Anderson v Michael Smith | 1-6 |
| Grand Slam of Darts 2021 | 2021/11/14 21:40 | Gary Anderson v Michael Smith | 2-5 |
| Players Championship 13 2021 | 2021/06/14 16:45 | Michael Smith v Gary Anderson | 4-6 |
Home History
| Players Championship 22 | 2023/09/27 15:15 | Ricardo Pietreczko v Gary Anderson | 0-6 |
| Players Championship 21 | 2023/09/05 15:15 | Daryl Gurney v Gary Anderson | 6-4 |
| World Matchplay 2023 | 2023/07/18 18:15 | Daryl Gurney v Gary Anderson | 11-4 |
| World Matchplay 2023 | 2023/07/15 21:15 | Dave Chisnall v Gary Anderson | 6-10 |
| Players Championship 13 | 2023/06/12 16:35 | Michael Smith v Gary Anderson | 8-7 |
| Players Championship 13 | 2023/06/12 16:00 | Gary Anderson v Damon Heta | 7-3 |
| Players Championship 13 | 2023/06/12 15:15 | Chris Dobey v Gary Anderson | 5-6 |
| European Tour 7 | 2023/05/07 18:25 | Michael van Gerwen v Gary Anderson | 6-1 |
Away History
| Players Championship 22 | 2023/09/27 14:35 | Callan Rydz v Michael Smith | 4-6 |
| Players Championship 22 | 2023/09/27 13:50 | Michael Smith v Darius Labanauskas | 6-5 |
| Players Championship 22 | 2023/09/27 12:40 | Michael Smith v Jurjen van der Velde | 6-3 |
| European Tour 12 | 2023/09/24 13:00 | Mike De Decker v Michael Smith | 6-2 |
| European Tour 12 | 2023/09/23 18:45 | Michael Smith v Jose De Sousa | 6-4 |
| World Series of Darts 2023 - finále | 2023/09/16 19:00 | Michael Smith v Raymond van Barneveld | 4-6 |
| Players Championship 20 | 2023/09/04 16:05 | Luke Humphries v Michael Smith | 6-2 |
| Players Championship 20 | 2023/09/04 15:25 | Josh Rock v Michael Smith | 3-6 |